Main content starts here, tab to start navigating

Located in Montauk Harbor

Tony's Meat Market

Butchery • Deli Sandwiches • Grocery • Coffee • Beer • Catering

Butcher Shop

At the heart of our business has always been providing prime, fresh cuts of quality meat. Everything from our famous Flat Iron to a monster Tomahawk is prepared with care, fresh, and daily in our store. Stop by today and find out why Tony’s has been the South Shore go-to for quality meats since 1990.

Our Story


Our catering menu offers a wide array of delicious full/half trays, appetizers, side dishes, and more to satisfy the appetites of your gathering. Contact us today and have our experts prepare a meal that your guests will not soon forget.

Inquire Now


Our new Deli section was created with the South Shore’s bustling lunch crowd in mind. Featuring Boar’s Head meat, including our own homemade cuts, our heroes, rolls, and wraps will not disappoint and are served fast and made to order. With regularly updated sandwich specials, including our local favorites, there’s always something new to try for lunch at the Deli!

View Menu

Grab N' Go

We’re food people at our core, and this passion for great-tasting food shines through in all of our prepared meals. Made fresh and available daily, we have a wide variety of grab & go options, including favorites like chicken parmigiana, grilled chicken, mac & cheese, twice-baked potatoes, a vast selection of salads, and more!

View Menu

Follow Us On Instagram